The Difference Between Fair and Just

Parshat Devarim

One of the greatest misunderstandings about justice is that it’s simply about fairness.

If everyone gets what they’re entitled to, justice has been served.

The Torah offers a richer definition.

It describes a lender who has every legal right to keep a poor person’s cloak as collateral for a loan.

Yet each evening, the cloak must be returned.

Not because the lender lost that right.

Because having the right doesn’t always make it the right thing to do.

Justice requires discernment.

Having the right doesn’t always make it the right thing to do.

It asks us to look beyond what we’re entitled to and understand what the moment truly requires.

Perhaps the same is true in our own lives.

There are times when the fair decision isn’t yet the complete one.

When doing what is legally justified isn’t yet doing what is truly just.

The Torah reminds us that justice isn’t only about applying principles.

It’s about applying them with wisdom, compassion, and discernment.

As Shabbat approaches, may we be blessed with the discernment to look beyond what is merely fair, the wisdom to recognize what is truly just, and the compassion to bring the two together in the way we live.

Shabbat Shalom!

Picture of Rabbi Shmulik Yeshayahu
Rabbi Shmulik Yeshayahu
Rabbi Shmuel Yeshayahu was born in Israel and received his rabbinic ordination from the Rabbinate of Israel. He is a Rabbi in Vancouver, BC. Since 2000 he has been providing mentoring, counseling, religious services, classes, and tutorials, as well as developing and leading Jewish programming for unaffiliated young adults. He is well known for his ability to make spirituality relevant to all people in all walks of life. You can follow him on Facebook @RabbiShmulikYeshayahu. Rabbi Shmuel Yeshayahu is the co-author of An MBA from Heaven.
Picture of Rabbi Shmulik Yeshayahu
Rabbi Shmulik Yeshayahu
Rabbi Shmuel Yeshayahu was born in Israel and received his rabbinic ordination from the Rabbinate of Israel. He is a Rabbi in Vancouver, BC. Since 2000 he has been providing mentoring, counseling, religious services, classes, and tutorials, as well as developing and leading Jewish programming for unaffiliated young adults. He is well known for his ability to make spirituality relevant to all people in all walks of life. You can follow him on Facebook @RabbiShmulikYeshayahu. Rabbi Shmuel Yeshayahu is the co-author of An MBA from Heaven.

Joy Doesn’t Have to Wait

Parshat Ki Tavo We spend a surprising amount of life waiting to enjoy it. When work calms down. When the kids are settled. When we finish what needs to be

Read More »

Strong Enough to Be Challenged

Parshat Shoftim This week’s parashah describes a society led not by one source of authority, but by several. Kings. Priests. Prophets. Judges. Each was entrusted with a different responsibility. Each

Read More »

Discover more from The Kollel

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading